[EricScott]

Currently an AT&T customer on a family plan w/ my wife. Have been PATIENTLY waiting for the Bold and now have my eyes on the Storm. After reading through every post I could find on the "Will the Storm work on AT&T" topic, it seems that the Vodafone version of the 9500 only supports UMTS 2100 which won't work on AT&T's 3G network (1900 I believe). So I could get an unlocked Vodafone 9500 but would be limited to EDGE speeds on AT&T, correct?

So now that it is [edit] rumored [edit] that Rodgers is coming out w/ the 9500, does anyone know if their version will be exactly the same as Vodafone's or is it different and will it work on AT&T's 3G network?

If not, I may switch to Verizon and pick up the 9530. I may even do a month to month plan and if AT&T ever releases a 3G storm, switch back and eBay my VZW Storm.

Any thoughts on whether Verizon's EVDO is better or worse than AT&T's 3G network in Manhattan? Who knows what is causing the Bold delay but there seems to be a lot of speculation that AT&T's 3G network isn't up to snuff. However I have also heard that it should be faster than EVDO. From a practical standpoint, which would be better in NYC?

TIA

Eric

[Jason Mark]

Originally Posted by EricScott

Currently an AT&T customer on a family plan w/ my wife. Have been PATIENTLY waiting for the Bold and now have my eyes on the Storm. After reading through every post I could find on the "Will the Storm work on AT&T" topic, it seems that the Vodafone version of the 9500 only supports UMTS 2100 which won't work on AT&T's 3G network (1900 I believe). So I could get an unlocked Vodafone 9500 but would be limited to EDGE speeds on AT&T, correct?

So now that Rodgers came out and announced that they are releasing the 9500, does anyone know if their version is exactly the same as Vodafone's or is it different and will it work on AT&T's 3G network?

If not, I may switch to Verizon and pick up the 9530. I may even do a month to month plan and if AT&T ever releases a 3G storm, switch back and eBay my VZW Storm.

Any thoughts on whether Verizon's EVDO is better or worse than AT&T's 3G network in Manhattan? Who knows what is causing the Bold delay but there seems to be a lot of speculation that AT&T's 3G network isn't up to snuff. However I have also heard that it should be faster than EVDO. From a practical standpoint, which would be better in NYC?

TIA

Eric

I was unaware that Rogers announced they were getting the Storm??

[sd5187]

No formal announcement yet of a Storm for Rogers.

To answer your question the Rogers version will work on the North American HSDPA/3G networks if/when they come out with one.

There is one in development but no specs released yet.

Rogers would not release a Storm without NA HSDPA.

[EricScott]

Confirmed: BlackBerry Storm coming to Rogers before Christmas! | BlackBerry Cool

[sd5187]

Rumor my friend...listen to the call. This is a standard Rogers response.

[EricScott]

Originally Posted by sd5187

To answer your question the Rogers version will work on the North American HSDPA/3G networks if/when they come out with one.

Rogers would not release a Storm without NA HSDPA.

Wasn't sure if Rodgers HSDPA was the same as AT&T - but I guess they are.

Thanks

[EricScott]

Originally Posted by sd5187

Rumor my friend...listen to the call. This is a standard Rogers response.

Wishful thinking I suppose. Honestly didn't even listen to the recording - saw a thread on that other not to be named forum and assumed people had checked it out.

[EricScott]

BTW - why on earth would RIM make the 3G radio on the 9500 (GSM version) 2100 MHz only? Why not do what they did w/ the Bold and make it 2100 / 1900 / 850 MHz so it works everywhere?

Seems like it will create a ton of confusion.

The more I have been reading about EVDO, it really does seem inferior to AT&T's 3G network - can't do simult voice and data, slower theoretical speeds, etc.

[Jason Mark]

Originally Posted by EricScott

BTW - why on earth would RIM make the 3G radio on the 9500 (GSM version) 2100 MHz only? Why not do what they did w/ the Bold and make it 2100 / 1900 / 850 MHz so it works everywhere?

Seems like it will create a ton of confusion.

The more I have been reading about EVDO, it really does seem inferior to AT&T's 3G network - can't do simult voice and data, slower theoretical speeds, etc.

Read this--> BlackBerry Storm Rains On North American 3G Parade | BlackBerryNews.com

[EricScott]

Thanks for the link. Doesn't make a ton of sense. Clearly could see why it is a good thing for Verizon but not sure why RIM would do it.

So if you are in the US your options are - get the VZW version which runs on EVDO, pay a ton of money for an unlocked Vodafone version that will only run EDGE or wait until Rodgers or AT&T release a 3G version of the Storm - judging by how quickly AT&T is rolling out the Bold that could be 2010.

Oh well.

[SLR2005]

this is c & p......

Confirmed: Rogers Wireless will not carry the BlackBerry Storm

Posted by Michael Bettiol on Oct 16, 2008 7:13 pm 16 comments Filed in BlackBerry, Handsets, RIM, Rogers, Rumors

Okay, time to put the final nail in the coffin of a stupid rumor that we reported on yesterday, one that some took a little too seriously. When we reported the rumor of the BlackBerry Storm heading to Rogers for Christmas we were confident that it was nothing more than the word of a few [...]

http://www.boygeniusreport.com/category/carriers-canadian/rogers/

[Jason Mark]

Originally Posted by SLR2005

this is c & p......

Confirmed: Rogers Wireless will not carry the BlackBerry Storm

Posted by Michael Bettiol on Oct 16, 2008 7:13 pm 16 comments Filed in BlackBerry, Handsets, RIM, Rogers, Rumors

Okay, time to put the final nail in the coffin of a stupid rumor that we reported on yesterday, one that some took a little too seriously. When we reported the rumor of the BlackBerry Storm heading to Rogers for Christmas we were confident that it was nothing more than the word of a few [...]

http://www.boygeniusreport.com/category/carriers-canadian/rogers/

New BlackBerry Magnum | BlackBerryNews.com

Rogers BlackBerry Lineup xxx8216;09 | BlackBerryNews.com

[Cory Scheuer]

ummm yes... Rogers will be getting a variant of the storm... in the next 3-5 months

[raynicolini]

it would be nice for Rogers to have the BOLD and STORM & the MAGNUM before AT&T even gets the Bold. I guess AT&T does not have true 3G to support these devices.

[TayeDrummer]

I gotta say it,

Eric, there is no "d" in "Rogers".

[EricScott]

Originally Posted by TayeDrummer

I gotta say it,

Eric, there is no "d" in "Rogers".

Sorry my bad. At least I got the subject right.

My fifth graded teacher was name Mrs. Rodgers and spelled it that way.

[dynot]

Originally Posted by EricScott

Sorry my bad. At least I got the subject right.

My fifth graded teacher was name Mrs. Rodgers and spelled it that way.

lol...we'll forgive him since he's a foreigner. Wait...maybe we're the foreigners.

in any case, any updates on if/when its coming to rogers. Last I read was it was expected in may '09. Hope that is way off!

Waiting till jan or feb is fine but may...that would be painfull.

[SLR2005]

Originally Posted by Jason Mark

New BlackBerry Magnum | BlackBerryNews.com

Rogers BlackBerry Lineup ‘09 | BlackBerryNews.com

the first link gives me this message....

Not Found
Sorry, but you are looking for something that isn't here.

[Jason Mark]

Originally Posted by SLR2005

the first link gives me this message....

Not Found
Sorry, but you are looking for something that isn't here.

It was taken down. I'm sure you can imagine why.

[SLR2005]

Originally Posted by Jason Mark

It was taken down. I'm sure you can imagine why.

i found other links around and had a look at the pics.....

i guess it might be bs.....and the phone will not be in production...

i still think the bold is one of the coolest bb's out there.....

well, i will still get the storm just cuz i have a hobby of collecting phones.....