I have my new Seidio desktop cradle and I am impressed. The quality is excellent and the fit is tight. You don't really "drop" your phone in, it takes a good push but it's nice that it fits so well. (note: I am referring to using it with a rubberized case on the BB)
I have knocked Seidio on their price for the rubberized case. I still stand by that assertion - way too expensive. This cradle, with the 15% discount, is worth the money. I recommend it if you would like the convenience of a cradle. Solid product.
-----
Suggestion >> There is no indication ON THE CRADLE when you lock the BB in that the connection has been made and it's charging. The screen doesn't light up and there is no LED change on the cradle. The light on the AC adapter does change. It would be nice to have some kind of feedback on the cradle (like having that green LED light only when the phone is connected - not all the time)