i have a rubber bb oem case and the leather swivel case. I have no problem getting it in and out. Works very nicely together. It also depends on which rubber case you have. I have the black one which seemed to be significantly less "sticky" than the other colors so that could also contribute but it works very nicely for me. Grand total of 20 bucks for both cases (eBay!) and I feel that my phone is very well protected in it (i also have an invishield screen cover)